Tropical Depression 9 Update

Well while many had written it off, Invest 99L did not listen and by Sunday we had Tropical Depression 9 on our hands just north of eastern Cuba. The Hurricane Center quickly jumped back on the bandwagon and issued basically the forecast track we still have right now. That track would take the system, likely a tropical storm by then, into the Florida coast somewhere near Cedar Key, Florida, right in the crook of Florida. The major models seem to support this scenario, indicating a trough will dip down into the southeast by mid week and turn the system to the northeast. Before we look at my ideas on the storm, here is the most current information based on Hurricane Hunters in the system.

At 1 PM CT Tuesday

Maximum Winds: 30 kt  Gusts: 45 kt
Minimum Central Pressure: 1005 mb
Radius of Circulation: 150 NM
Radius of Maximum Wind: 60 NM
Eye Diameter: N/A

In this animated loop of the visible satellite imagery, you can sort of see where the center is located by the clouds at top-left of the cloud mass curving south into the system. The center is actually located just under the northwest corner of the cloud mass. It has not yet wrapped up completely around the center but is very close to Tropical Storm intensity. It would not surprise me if we see it named later tonight. Now it is not easy to see, but looking closely at the swirling clouds, it appears the system is moving predominately to the west very slowly. Officially, the NHC says the motion is west-northwest at 9 mph. That has a lot to do with my problems with the current forecast track. This system has been consistently running south of where the models said it should go. This time last week it was supposed to impact the central Florida coast. By later in the week, we were told the system would likely impact just south of Miami and into the Florida Keys. Late week, the system was supposed to pass right through the Florida Straits. But each time, it actually traveled farther to the south, actually hugging the Cuban coast until yesterday. So each forecast got shifted south. Fast forward to now and the system is still farther south than Key West.

Let’s take a look at what the models have forecast over the past few days. We are looking at where the models expected the storm center to be at 1 PM today. It shows the projected position and then the time and date the forecast was issued by the NHC.

FORECAST 1PM TODAY            FORECAST ISSUED

  • 25.1N  87.6W                                    4PM SUN
  • 24.7N  87.1W                                    4AM MON
  • 24.6N  86.6W                                   4PM MON
  • 24.2N  87.3W                                   4AM TUE
  • 24.2N  87.4W                                   Actual Location

Do you see it? The position in longitude, or West, has been pretty consistent. But check out the forecast latitude, or North. It has consistently tried to move the system farther north, in a direction of west-northwest or even northwest, But each time the position was reassessed and a new forecast issued, they had to push farther south. Until we reach now and find the system almost a full degree south of where the models forecast it to be. This system has continued to defy the models and run south of projections. Again, I fully agree with the major global models that a trough will dig into the northern Gulf over the next 72 hours or so. If it picks up the system, it would turn from west-northwest, to the northwest, then north, and finally northeast.

First off that is a lot of turning. But the system is relatively small and not moving that fast, so it is very capable of making the turn. But I see two kinks in the current forecast. First off, it is failing to accept the general trend of this system staying farther south than expected. And this trend moves the system quietly farther west over time. That means the turn to the north and northeast takes place further west and also pushes landfall to the west. This is a near certainty unless something happens very quick in the general motion. Second, the farther south the system stays, the later the trough picks it up since it has to wait for the trough to dig that far. We are not yet seeing fronts sweep through and move well into the Gulf. SO how deep will this trough be? I am not sure?

This is the latest animated water vapor loop of the eastern US and Gulf of Mexico. It shows us the major movements of the air masses. If you look near the junction of Florida, Georgia, and the Atlantic Ocean, you will see a swirl in the clouds. That is what should pick up the system and shoot it off to the northeast. But looking at the motion of clouds in the northern Gulf, I do not see it exerting an influence on clouds near the coast, nevertheless well south in the Gulf.

So my gut feeling is that the idea of a landfall near Cedar Key is a long shot right now. I would take the projected path and keep moving it west until we see the storm begun to make a major turn. I currently feel Berwick Bay and Louisiana will dodge the bullet on this one. But if you plan to head for anywhere from Biloxi to Panama City, keep your eyes on this system until it makes that turn. The only threat I could foresee to Louisiana would be if the trough misses the system allowing it to king of meander in the central Gulf looking for direction. Based on the models, I think this is a long shot, say less than 15%, which is about what I also give a landfall on the Peninsula of Florida. My best guess right now would be extreme western Florida, but it is a guess.

As for intensity, I think this is nothing more than a tropical storm. That has its positives and negatives. On the positive side, you have little wind damage and no surge. On the negative side of things, tropical storms are huge rain makers and tornado generators. We do not need either of those things any Louisiana right now! Finally, keep your eyes on the far eastern Atlantic. The models are hinting at a major storm developing over the next week, with none of the inhibiting effects 99L saw. And it is pointed somewhere at the US in the models. We shall see???

99L is Still Fighting

A quick update on our friend 99L. While some are starting to count it out, I am not ready to do so yet. It has maintained convection to the south and east of the center for the past 36 hours. It has been conjectured by some that there was no longer a low level circulation. But the loop shown below tells a different story. The system is spinning away on the northern coast of Cuba. This will inhibit it until it moves away from the Cuban mountains, but it is still there. And as far as I am concerned: If there is a circulation and three of four thunderstorms in the same area over 90 degree water, its tropical till it dissipates. I am going to save models for later today or tomorrow as they are all over the place right now. But it appears some form of 99L will spin into the Gulf early next week. What is does there is currently the 64,000 question among tropical meteorologists. We shall see?

99L Lives to Fight Another Day

Just a short note tonight as not much has really changed since yesterday, other than 99L continues to fight for life. It is more impressive today as thunderstorms have continued to regenerate near the center, though are not yet sustaining themselves. Models are pretty much unchanged for the most part, just waiting to see if, when and where the system decides to spin-up. I would still give us a 60-70 percent chance of an organized system in the Gulf by early week gaining strength. How strong? Where it goes? And all the other questions hinge on it getting a bit more organized. Shear is down, though still there. But conditions will improve as the system moves westward. Hopefully, I’ll have more one way or the other Saturday morning.

99L Update Delayed

I will be updating the progress of 99L today but will hold off until later this afternoon for a couple of reasons. First, 99L has shown signs of life over the past few hours with big storms starting to go up around the center. I want to see of these persist, as there is still a bit of shear. Second, I really want to see the afternoon run of the ECMWF before writing the blog.

On a second note, there is currently no organization in the elongated area of disturbed weather in the central Gulf. It is being monitored but other than increasing rain chances for the northern and western Gulf Coast, I do not see any big issue there at the moment. 99L remains our major player into next week.

More later this afternoon …

99L is a Fighter: Next 36 hours make the difference!

Here is the Thursday update on the “little system that could,” good ole Invest 99L. If anything, the system looks worse than it did yesterday at this time. But there are some subtle signs things may be about to change. First off there is now a low-level closed circulation obvious on the visible satellite images.

If you look at the tip of the arrow, just north of Hispaniola, you can see the banding of the low-level circulation. Observations and hurricane hunter aircraft have found a 1008 mb central pressure with sustained winds of 35 knots and gusts to 45 knots. It has an overall circulation of 140 miles diameter and a maximum wind zone of 80 miles diameter. It is a healthy system, so why isn’t it named?

Because of what is missing from yesterday.  All those big thunderstorms surrounding the center are gone. Well not really gone, just displaced. They are well to the east and south of the system. So what’s up? Well the dry air is a gone, but that nasty shear zone we talked about yesterday is now directly over 99L and at its most intense. As you can see in the next image, a small lobe of highly intense negative wind shear is right over the center of the system.

The left arrow points to where the center is at the time of the image. Remember, it is the red lines which are unfavorable to development. Yellow indicates a favorable environment. It may be hard to see, but the right arrow points to a number “30” indicating that winds of 30 knots or greater are pushing all of the thunderstorms to the east and south. Add that 99L is chugging west-northwest at about 20 knots and that equals a true shear of over 50 knots. Few systems can take that kind of beating. But 99L is hanging in there. And most importantly, the shear models indicate the shear lobe will pull east as 99L moves west into an area with highly favorable conditions. Remember the red lines are unfavorable, but those green lines equal favorable conditions. There is lots of green just ahead of 99L!

The bottom line here is that the next 36 hours are critical. If the circulation is still there in 36 hours as the strong shear is replace by favorable conditions, we will likely be looking at Hermine and she will be poised to steadily intensify. My guess is that she will make it. Had the center been closer to Hispaniola, with its huge mountains, and not over 85 degree waters, I would say no way. But unless those shear models are wrong, I feel we have a tropical storm within 36 hours.

So what happens if Hermine is sitting in the Bahamas Friday afternoon or evening? Well the models have settled down a bit and have a better feel for the system. But there is some volatility still in their outputs. In some ways, the models are also influenced b y their peers. In the afternoon run of the ECMWF yesterday, the Euro actually shifted its tracks to a recurve over Florida. Why? Because of the erroneous output of the GFS model, it was accounting for something not truly there. When the latest run came out this morning, it was pretty much the same as we looked at yesterday.

It is a track that is perfect for intensifying a system. Again, ignore the actual individual lines and look at the cone of probability they project. Basically, they show a system moving through the southern Bahamas, then through the Florida Straits, and slowly bending west-northwest into the Gulf of Mexico. What is missing in that track? If you said it does not cross any major land mass, give yourself a gold star. If this track holds, the system will miss Hispaniola, stay north of Cuba and south of anything but maybe extreme southern Florida and the Keys. Land masses inhibit development and intensification, while most of the time actually disrupting systems. It would not be a good thing for Florida if it crossed the width of the state, but it would be a good thing for those of us along the northern Gulf Coast. It would slow development. That does not appear to be the case.

99L_intensity_latest

As for intensity, there is a bit of hope there. Most of the projections show a strong Cat I storm sitting due south of say Pensacola Tuesday heading toward the Louisiana Coastline somewhere. Giving that the trend is slow intensification and it is likely another day or so from landfall, we could interpolate a weak Cat II storm at landfall.

Again, all of this is a week out on a system which has yet to get its act together. That said the models seem to think it will come together and begin to slowly gain strength over the open waters of the far western Atlantic, Florida Straits, and Gulf of Mexico, all of which are a cauldron of pent up thermal energy just waiting on a system to come along. In addition, it is often easy today to get too caught up in models and projections, while ignoring that trait which separates good tropical meteorologists from the so-so one; their gut. In so  many ways, all weather forecasting is as much an art as science. The models are only as good as the data we put into them. Over the continental US, we have a high density of data points and our models do a pretty darn good job. They do a good job over the open waters as well but must do so with far less data. So the key is to step back and ask yourself, what would I have thought about this system 25 years ago before the supermodels? Most of the old guys out there like myself seem to think this system will make it. Over the past 10 days, it has run through some of the most adverse conditions you could imagine, yet we are still talking about it. I just have to believe that once it gets some good conditions, it is going to take off.

Again please do not focus exactly on those forecast paths. At five days they may be off by up to 300 miles either side of the centerline. But bottom line, if you live anywhere from Corpus Christi to Pensacola on the Northern Gulf Coast you need to be doing two things: First, keep an eye on then progress of the system and listen to what the NHC and NWS have to say. Second, begin very preliminary preparations for a possible threat from a tropical system in the middle of next week. Even if nothing come of 99L, you will have that done when the next threat appears and be better off for it!