A Different Threat

We are still months away from the hurricane season, yet dark clouds are still approaching rapidly. Just as I have used CajunWx to keep friends and family informed about happenings in the Gulf and tropics, I felt it might be a good idea to also discuss the coronavirus crisis. As with tropical weather, I do not portend to be an expert in virology or infectious diseases. That said a decade of emergency room and trauma nursing along with lifelong studies do make it possible for me to wade through the ocean of scientific papers pouring in on the coronavirus and decern trends in the information.

Probably the best place to start is the name, or rather names, of this outbreak. I say this after watching a trained doctor on one of the networks leave all viewers more confused than when they started. The common name of “coronavirus” stems from the fact that the virus which causes the current outbreak comes from the family called coronaviridae, Latin for coronavirus. The specific name of the virus is SARS CoV-2 which basically means it is “Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus #2.” While it is closely related to the SARS CoV virus which caused the outbreak that infected 8,098 people in 2002, killing 774, the current outbreak involves a “novel” or new virus. Thus the new name. Finally, we also name major outbreaks of infectious disease. In this case, the disease outbreak is known as Covid-19, the coronavirus outbreak originating in 2019.

So now that we know the names associated with the outbreak, let’s begin with what a virus actually is. At its simplest, a virus is a non-living particle, which carries DNA or RNA, and must hijack a living cell to make it do the work of reproduction. The structure of a virus is quite simple, with most having only three components: The first is a strand of either DNA or RNA which holds the code for reproducing the virus. The second is a protein shell or capsule which surrounds the genetic material and protects it. Finally, on the surface of the capsule will be a number of receptors which allow the virus to bond to living cells. There is no metabolism or life, just the ability to reprogram a cell. This means you cannot truly ever “kill” a virus, as it was never alive. You can though render it safe by a number of means. Heat, disinfectants and such work well as does just common soap.

A representation of SARS CoV-2

The SARS CoV-2 virus would look something like the image above if we were able to take a look at it. But that would take a specialized piece of equipment known as an electron microscope. The SAR CoV-2 virus is about 120 nanometers across. As there 1000 nanometers in a micron, we can see that the virus is quite small. The spikes that cover the surface of the virus are its key to entering the body. Those spikes work like a key when they find a cell in the body with an ACE2 receptor. ACE2 stands for the angiotensin-converting enzyme-2 but don’t worry about what that is, just that the majority of the cells in the human respiratory tract have such receptors.

The diagram above from The Economist shows how the virus uses the ACE-2 receptors to enter into human cells and take over the cell machinery to make it produce thousands and thousands of copies of the virus until the cell literally bursts to spread the new viruses through the body. Each new virus particle then attempts to hijack another cell and the process continues until the body builds a sufficient immune response to fight off the assault.

How easily is Sars CoV-2 transmitted? To determine this, scientists use a mathematical calculation known as R0 or R naught. R0 basically measures how many people will be infected by a single infected person. If the R0 for an infectious agent is less than one, then the disease is likely not to spread and eventually die out. If the R0 is equal to one, the one new infection will occur for each old one. Such diseases will stay alive and stable but will not become an epidemic. When R0 is greater than one, we have the potential for an epidemic.

So how does SARS CoV-2 stack up? The R0 for the MERS outbreak was less than one. The flu has an R0 of 1.3, around that of the common cold. The ebola virus has an R0 of 2.0, mumps an R0 of 4.7, and smallpox an R0 of 7.0. The R0 based on numbers from China for the SAR CoV-2 virus was set at 2.2, meaning every infected person passes the disease on to another 2.2 people. As we get more data out of Europe, it appears the SARS CoV-2 R0 may be closer to 2.7 to 3.0. Only time and more data will tell.

Another item related to the R0 concept of disease transmission is that it only relates to those who have no natural immunity for the infectious agent. In other words, even though the R0 for the flu is 1.3, major outbreaks are rare because of both natural immunity from previous exposure and the widespread use of a vaccine. However, in 1918 the world saw an outbreak of the H1N1 flu variant, at the time a novel strain which had never been seen before by man. The R0 of the Spanish Flu as it was called, was around 2.1, but due to the lack of natural immunity and the war-ravaged state of the world, it claimed over 20 million lives. Therein lies the rub with SARS CoV-2, it has a relatively high R0 of say 2.2 – 3.0, and the world population has no natural immunity. We also lack a vaccine, with the nearest likely a year off, or any drugs which effectively fight the disease process. The state of mankind’s health and medical technology are far beyond 1918 but this outbreak will likely continue to grow unchecked without strict isolation procedures. Basically, we are just beginning to see the ravaging effects of SARS CoV-2 and will be living with it for months to over a year. Current estimates by the CDC say 30-90 million Americans could be infected before we are done!

But how deadly is the Covid-19 outbreak? Some articles on the internet would have you believe it is less deadly than the seasonal flu. They are wrong. Covid-19 tends to kill about 3.5% of those who are infected. The seasonal flu, on the other hand, has a mortality rate of just 0.1%. And once again the Covid-19 death rate is based mostly on data out of China, while the data out of Europe is showing that 3.5% may be too low. So the Covid-19 outbreak is far more deadly than the seasonal flu. It is also worth noting that even with a vaccine and natural immunity, over 34 million will be infected and 20,000 die this year from the seasonal flu in the United States alone. Add in a multiplier of 35, the difference between 3.5% and 0.1%, and Covid-19 could claim up to 700,000 lives before it is done.

Put in the above context and taking into consideration the ease with which Covid-19 spreads and its high mortality rate, along with what is happening in Europe, which is a mere two-weeks further along in this than us, and we are likely in for a long haul. Further restrictions, including the suspension of flights and even travel, are possible if not probable. This is also not something which will play out in weeks but rather months. The world is facing a crisis, unlike anything it has seen in over 100 years. Yes, it is scary. But the more we learn about the science of SARS CoV-2 and Covid-19, the easier it is for us to accept the restrictions which are likely to come. I will follow up in the coming days and weeks as number change and we gain more clarity. For now, listen to government officials. Isolate as much as you can and pray something slows this deadly juggernaught!

It’s That Time of Year Again!

While we have not yet reached June 1 and the official start of the 2018 Atlantic Hurricane Season, it looks like nature may be poised to jump the gun by a few days. Models have been hinting for about a week that something might try to form near the Yucatan Peninsula and move into the Gulf of Mexico late this week into the Memorial Day Weekend. The most consistent indicator of a developing system has been the European Model, which also happens to be arguably the best model for tropical systems. The US based GFS model has also hinted at a developing system but had a tougher job nailing down what it might do. Things have become a bit clearer over the weekend though as we now have several models pointing to development in the central to eastern Gulf by mid- to late week and some sort of system moving inland over the Memorial Day weekend.

The European ECMWF Model is still the most solid, showing a 996 mb system with winds near 40 knots approaching the Louisiana coast mid-weekend. There are a couple items of interest in this image of the 0000 UTC run of the Euro. The familiar bulls-eye of a surface low centered just about due south of Atchafalaya Bay is pretty obvious. But note the rain pattern. The heaviest rains early Sunday morning would be from the mouth of the Mississippi River to the north shore of Lake Pontchartrain, as well as over much of Florida. This is due to the fact that the system will likely not become very organized until it nears the coast, where waters are much warmer. Until then it is just a disorganized low with lots of rain mostly on the east side and with much less to the west.

If we move ahead with the Euro, we see that early Monday morning, the system is a little better organized, even with its proximity to land, showing a more concentric pattern, lower pressure of 994 mb, and winds over 40 knots. By early Tuesday morning, the system is now near Lake Charles with a central pressure of 993 mb and winds still near 40 knots. It is only on Tuesday, image to left, that the rain from the system separates from the moisture plume over Florida. It is this quirk, a sort of double system which seems to be giving the GFS  problems. However, as of this morning, the Canadian “CFS”  and the US Navy “NAVGEM” models. are both showing a similar system, though those models lie a bit east of the Euro, from the mouth of the Mississippi to the Mississippi Gulf Coast. But all then move it westward along the coast through early next week.

So what does all this mean? Keep a close eye on the weather as the week progresses and you make plans for the weekend, especially Sunday. It is still way to early to know if or where a system may form. Regardless, there is a strong likelihood that the Northern Gulf Coast and Florida will very likely get some rain and wind for the second half of the Memorial Day Weekend into early next week. As the system is projected to be a slow mover to the west, there will likely be heavy rainfall in certain areas, along with gusty winds and heavy thunderstorms in the impacted parts of the coastline. As with most early season systems, it is the rainfall which is likely to be the biggest problem. Also, expect these landfall projections to change as the week progresses. Everywhere, from Key West to the coastal bend of Texas could see some impacts from whatever forms. For the moment we are sort of in the center of things is about all we can say for now.

Finally, the way this system is projected to develop: that being a disorganized system which gets stronger as it approaches the coast is also what most of the major hurricane prognosticators are projecting for this hurricane season. We will likely see fewer storms form way out in the Atlantic and track for days across the ocean. This is due to cooler waters in the eastern and central Atlantic. However, waters in the Gulf, northwestern Caribbean and along the Atlantic seaboard are projected to be warmer than normal. So we may see more homegrown systems in the Gulf, NW Caribbean and western Atlantic. That may keep overall numbers down, but mean more system which do form impact the US. Time will tell? For now all eyes to the Gulf this week as we see what plays out. I will update mid-week or sooner as conditions warrant.

Harvey: The Sequels

Harvey is the storm that just would not quit. It formed in the Atlantic and died in the Caribbean. It reformed in the Bay of Campeche and now threatens the middle Texas coast as a Cat 2, potentially Cat 3 Major Hurricane. If you live on the Texas coast, between Corpus Christi and Freeport, you need to be listening to local action statements and rapidly preparing for the impact of a potentially major hurricane. That means winds to 120 mph, a surge of anywhere from 12-15 feet, and rainfall amounts approaching three feet. This is no longer a potentially deadly situation but a probably deadly situation. Get out while you can!

So what about the rest of us? Well let’s recap what we know right now: Harvey at 9 am was located at 26.5 N 95.9W or about 135 SSE of Port O’Connor Texas. Max winds are 110 mph and climbing, it is moving NW at 10 mph and has a central pressure of 948 mb. This remains a quickly intensifying storm and it should be Cat 3 as it approaches the Texas coast. One way or another, our friends from Corpus to  Freeport are going to feel the brunt of a Cat 3 hurricane over the next 24 hours. And if this were a normal storm, it would push well inland and fall aprt with the remnants swept up to the NE eventually by the jet stream. Not Harvey!

The image to the right is what the hurricane center is thinking will happen. Quite frankly it is the best case scenario for the upper Texas and Louisiana coasts. It depicts a storm which comes ashore as a Major Hurricane early Saturday and by Sunday is about 60 miles inland as a hurricane and stalled. By early Monday it is back near where it made landfall, late Tuesday near Freeport as a Tropical Storm right on the coast, and Wednesday over Galveston as a Tropical Storm. Harvey, the storm that would not quit.

If this plays out as the actual path of the system, those of us on the Upper Texas and Louisiana coasts will get lots of rain, more on that in a bit, and some windy tropical storm like winds and conditions. All in all, not a bad outcome from a Cat 3 storm. But the problem is, as the NHC always tells us, don’t look at the path line itself, but rather the general motion. This is because the actual path is likely to deviate by as much as 60 miles, even in the short term. Therein lies the rub. The Hurricane Center has been shifting its products a bit to the east consistently over the past few days as the major models fight about the future course of the storm. The European model, arguably the best in the world has one idea and the US GFS model another.

Now is not the time to get into a discussion on the accuracy of various models. I will just say that the Euro has done a great job with Harvey so far and the GFS a good job. The major variance has been with what happens as Harvey approaches landfall. The Euro has consistently brought the storm barely inland, stalled it then kicked it out to the northeast back over the Gulf. The GFS wants to push it further inland towards San Anton io, then have it move eastward hugging the coast. Well except for yesterday when it took it towards Mexico?? In the end, we are not sure of where Harvey will go once it reaches the coast. The GFS and other models based off of its core model lie along the NHC track. The other half of the models follow the Euro, which has an intact system re-emerge over the Gulf before heading northeast early next week. What actually happens will mean a world of difference with regards to winds and tides for the are from Houston/Galveston to Berwick Bay.

This is why. This is a snapshot from the NAM model, the model used by the US Navy. It shows the position of the “remnants” of Harvey next Tuesday as a strong Tropical Storm due south of Cameron and heading to the NNE. The European Model depicts nearly the same scenario. Even the HRRR, the US tropical specialty model depicts something like this but maybe shifted west by 30 miles. The take away from all of this is we need to watch carefully and see how far inland Harvey’s center makes it. If it gets close to San Antonio, then the GFS is likely on the mark. If it makes it only to Victoria or so before stalling, the Euro camp is likely right. My gut right now lies with the Euro but it not with a great deal of certainty. What we absolutely do not want is Harvey to reach the coast and stall with it’s eye over water! Possible? Sure but not likely right now at least.

All that said, one thing is certain: Everyone from the Houston metro area well eastward into Louisiana is in for a lot of rain. And it really again depends on which of the model solutions verifies as to whether we talk in inches or a foot or more! The NHC has put out a rainfall prediction based upon the GFS course scenario which call for four or more inches of rain from Mobile to Brownsville, with a maximum of nearly three feet of rain near and around the area of initial landfall.

You can see from the image that the Berwick Bay region is predicted to be in the 10-15 inch swath, Cameron could approach 20 inches, and the Houston Mertroplex would be looking at 20-plus inches. Should the Euro/NAM solution be the right one, we would likely elongate the areas of heaviest rain farther to the east by say 75 miles. Bottom line, regardless of the winds and such Harvey brings us, we will be looking at lots of rainfall. Those in Houston who historically flood may need to be thinking about exit routes if waters begin to rise. Harvey will likely be known much more for his rainfall and flooding than his wind damage.

Look for updates over the next couple of days as the future track of Harvey becomes more certain. That will allow us to the north and east of the first landfall to prepare for Harvey Part III, whatever and where ever that may be. Until then, stay safe and stay dry!

Tropical Storm Warning

The National Hurricane Center has issued a Tropical Storm Warning for the Louisiana Coast from Intracoastal City to the mouth of the Pearl River. A tropical storm warning means tropical storm conditions, with winds in excess of 39 mph are expected in the warning area within the next 48 hours. In this case we could see those winds and storms within 24-36 hours.

All of this is in reference to Investigation 93L now known as Potential Tropical Cyclone Three. In an effort to stay ahead of the curve, the NHC can now issue watches and warning even when a system is still forming like this one. Two satellite passes earlier today showed surface winds in excess of tropical storm strength associated with the system getting organized north of the Yucatan Peninsula. The models had predicted this system to form as long as a week ago but were unsure when and where it would form or go. Things have become clearer as the system got into the Gulf over the past 24 hours.

This is the latest visible satellite loop from this afternoon and you can see the system trying to get organized in the southern Gulf off of the Yucatan. In the final frames you can see what looks like an exposed closed center. Thatgood news in all of this: this is not likely to become a hurricane despite very warm Gulf waters. Inhibiting the system is an upper-level low pressure area centered south of Galveston. This upper low has brought us the very dry weather of the past week as it cut off from the upper-level flow and churned over the Louisiana-Texas border region. As we have discussed here in the past, upper-level lows bring with them shear that makes it difficult for thunderstorms to grow upward into the atmosphere and wrap around the center.

There is an issue though. The upper-level low is now weakening and pulling off to the southwest towards the Bay of Campeche. So while it will impact the growing tropical system for a while, the impact will lessen over the next day or so. 

In the GOES Water Vapor Loop at left you can see the growing tropical system covering the eastern half of the Gulf. To its west is a section of browns and blacks. That is the dry air associated with the upper-low. Notice a couple of things about the upper low: first of all, it is moving now and moving to the southwest; and second, it is “filling” or falling apart. Notice how the clouds with the tropical system are moving westward, while moisture over Texas, whiter colors pushes in from the west. Finally, see all of those white streamers flowing in from the lower left. These are all signs the upper-low and its shear will soon be less of a factor, allowing a more concentric system to  form.

In general, the models are indicating a system with winds no more than say 50 mph. In fact the NHC is being a bit more conservative with top winds only reaching 45 mph. But this is one system where winds are the least of our worries. PTC #3 is a massive rain maker. And with some of the models indicating it may slow as it approaches the coast, we could be talking about dangerous amounts of rain. Tropical storms have historically been some of the most intense rain makers of all tropical systems, with some dumping up to 30 inches of rain. We are not talking about those kind of numbers here, but double-digit rain amounts are likely near where the center crosses land and to the east of that.

Normally, we would feel pretty good about being on the western side of the warning area. But it is more related to the lopsided nature of the system than the potential landfall site. Best guess is the center will come inland just to our west. That is purely a guess but probably a good one. We will in all likelihood be on the wet side of the storm. And if the system manages to wrap up and become more organized, the Tropical Storm Watch from Intracoastal City to High Island Texas may be upgraded to a warning as well.

As you can see from the latest model runs, we are pretty unlikely to avoid the effects of this system. Thankfully, it will be a rain maker and not a wind machine. It has been a while since we have  had a tropical system impact the Berwick Bay area. So this would be a good time to take care of all of those early season activities and prepare your home and family for what is shaping up as a busy season. I will begin to outline my thoughts on newly formed Tropical Storm Brett in the Atlantic once PTC#3/Cindy is gone. We could be looking at Brett or his remnants in the Gulf by next week.

An Air Force Reserve Hurricane Hunter is currently investigating the Potential Tropical Cyclone Three as I type this blog. If it finds Tropical Storm Cindy has formed out there, I will update this blog with that info. I am also considering moving from these text-based blogs to a YouTube video blog in the near future. Just a heads up. Until the next update, stay safe and prepare!

 

Matthew a Monster in the Making With an Unclear Path

Tropical Storm Matthew formed this morning out of Invest 97L about 35 miles southeast of St Lucia in the Leeward Islands, or about 2250 miles west-southwest of Berwick Bay. Yes it is a long way off and only a tropical storm with winds of about 60 mph. It is really just starting to spin up and pull the winds and weather in around the center. That said most of the models put the system as a 90-knot hurricane a couple hundred miles south of Jamaica late Saturday. Barring crossing any major landmasses, conditions will be ripe for further intensification and many of the models are predicting a Cat 4 if not a Cat 5 storm in Matthew’s future. A long ways off for sure but the trend will definitely be towards a big one!

So where is this monster in the making headed? That is definitely the $64,000 question this morning and no one has a clue what will actually happen after the weekend. All of the models turn the system more northerly, but in degree of turn they diverge greatly. The major models have landfalls anywhere from the Mexican coast to no landfall at all out in the central Atlantic. So why even predict? In truth, it is a little clearer than that. We will look at that in a bit.

First, let’s look at what is causing all of the variance in the models. In essence it is the wonderful first taste of fall weather that began yesterday and will truly blossom over the next three days. Highs not making 80 and lows near 60 with wonderful dry air and clear skies. It has been a while! But it is an odd scenario generating this wonderful weather. Normally we would see a big deep low pressure center crossing through the Great Lakes, with a cold front trailing to the south followed by a big high pressure area building in its wake. But this time, a piece of the big low is going to split off and drift south over Georgia and stall as it is out of the main upper air flow. Eventually, it pulls out to the north ahead of the next front sometime over the weekend. It is that cut-off low which holds the key to where Matthew will head. If the low pulls out quickly and weakens with high pressure rushing in to replace it, the Gulf is definitely in the cross hairs. If the low is stronger and/or slower to pull out, it is Florida and the East Coast under the gun. Here are the two model ensembles of potential tracks from the two top models in the world. Courtesy of Mike’s Weather Page, by the way. Not exactly a match!

On top is the European (ECMWF) Model for the next 14 days. On the bottom is the US (GFS) Model for the same period. As I explain below, interpreting ensembles is an art. But basically, the two top models in the world have very different ideas. Ignore all those  squiggles and look at the red outlined cones I have added. You will note I have also ignored the major outliers in each case. For instance, some of the ECMWF runs show the storm going west into Mexico near Tampico. That is highly unlikely at least for now, so I have it outside the cone. But you can see how difficult this is to judge.

As I said, ensemble models are not the easiest to understand. The best analogy I can think of is this. Someone has started cooking a huge gumbo to feed hundreds and just walked off leaving you to you to finish it. All you know is what ingredients went into the pot but not how much of each. Health regulations say you cannot sample the whole gumbo pot to check its flavor until it is completely finished. In fact you can’t taste it at all, even a small sample in another bowl, until you have made your changes to that small bowl. So you take about 20 small samples from the big pot and add a bit of this or that to each, covering all your bases, then taste them to see what needs to be added to the big pot to make it Louisiana good.

That is sort of what the ensembles do. They tweak the potential outcomes to cover all the minor changes which might take place. Unfortunately, we can’t sample them until the very end in this case, when we actually know where Matthew went. However, as we watch each successive model run and see which changes seem to be matching what is actually happening, we learn how to target our tweaks for a narrower cone. But it takes many runs and there are only a couple runs of each a day.

Now I know some of you 😉 You want to know what my gut says and will message me as soon as I say “we just have to wait.” So here it goes but this is a flat out guess and confidence is not high. At the moment, I am leaning towards the ECMWF solution for two reasons. First, the ECMWF, while far from perfect, is the best model in the world. It is the only 4-demensional model out there until the GFS fully integrates temporal data analysis in the near future. Second, the GFS has played this cut-off low as stronger and bigger than appears to be materializing. It would have had us in the mid-70s for highs and mid-50s for lows. That is quite a big miss from what appears to be coming. The ECMWF just appears to have a better handle on the cut-off low right now. If that trend holds, the ECMWF should also have a better handle on the future track of Matthew. But man that is a lot of “ifs.” Too many for any degree of confidence.

Even if the ECMWF scenario verifies, the cone runs from Corpus Christi to Savannah right now, over a thousand miles. Not exactly a pinpoint scenario. But given the extreme uncertainty not just in these models but many others, that wide cone also seems more appropriate to me right now than the narrow GFS cone. But only time will tell. Keep an eye on Matthew as you enjoy our first gorgeous Fall weekend after months of hot and muggy/downright wet weather. By early next week the models will have a better handle on things and we will know who needs to be taking action to protect life and property ahead of Matthew. If this were not complicated enough already, Miche and I are set to fly to Boston over the Columbus Day weekend to visit Evan. So we have a potential of dealing with Matthew either here and up there depending on which track verifies 🙁 Got to love those tropics. For now, just enjoy this wonderful weather!